Sarah Hyland's Theatrical Journey: From 'Little Shop of Horrors' to 'The Great Gatsby
Sarah Hyland, best known for her role as Haley Dunphy on the hit sitcom "Modern Family," has transitioned to hosting television shows after the series ended. She hosted two seasons of "Love Island USA," a reality dating show that combines elements of "Big Brother" and "Bachelor in Paradise." However, in March 2024, she announced on Instagram that she would not be returning to host the show for a third season due to a new project she had committed to.
Hyland's departure from "Love Island USA" was due to her landing a role in the Off-Broadway production of "Little Shop of Horrors." She took on the role of Audrey in the musical, which directly conflicted with the filming schedule of the reality dating series. Despite her popularity as a host, she had to step away from the show to pursue her passion for theater.
Starting on May 28, 2024, Sarah Hyland joined the Off-Broadway cast of "Little Shop of Horrors" as Audrey, marking her return to the theater scene. Her role in the musical overlapped with the filming dates of "Love Island USA," preventing her from continuing as the host of the show. This scheduling conflict led to her decision to prioritize her theater commitments over her television hosting duties.
Following her successful run in "Little Shop of Horrors," which concluded on September 29, 2024, Hyland went on to star as Daisy Buchanan in the Broadway production of "The Great Gatsby" in 2025. Her return to the stage showcased her versatility as an actress and her dedication to pursuing diverse roles in both television and theater.