Premier League 2025-26 Season: Top 10 Worst Signings and Their Struggles
Premier League clubs have once again flexed their financial muscle during the 2025-26 season, with significant spending in the transfer market. Despite a record-breaking summer transfer window, the January window was relatively quiet. However, the total expenditure on new signings has been substantial. Not all of these signings have lived up to expectations, leading to some high-profile disappointments. Sports Illustrated has compiled a list of the top 10 worst signings of the season.
Conor Gallagher's move to Tottenham Hotspur for $46.6 million has not gone as planned, with the midfielder struggling to make an impact. Despite his commendable work rate, Gallagher has failed to impress Tottenham supporters with his performances on the pitch. As Spurs battle against relegation, they are hoping for Gallagher to step up and deliver, but so far, he has fallen short of expectations.
Liam Delap's transition from Ipswich Town to Chelsea for $40.6 million has been underwhelming, with the striker managing only three goals in 38 appearances. Delap's lackluster performances have raised doubts about his ability to succeed at a top club like Chelsea. With competition for places fierce, Delap needs to improve quickly to secure his future at the club.
James McAtee's move to Nottingham Forest from Manchester City for $40.6 million has not yielded the desired results, with the attacking midfielder struggling to make an impact. Despite playing 20 games for Forest, McAtee has failed to impress under multiple managers. His lack of consistency and poor performances have left fans frustrated with his contribution to the team.
Anthony Elanga's transfer from Manchester United to Newcastle United for $74 million has not gone according to plan, with the winger failing to replicate his previous form. Elanga's slow start at Newcastle has raised concerns about his ability to justify his hefty price tag. With time on his side, Elanga will need to improve his performances to meet the expectations set by his transfer fee.
Armando Broja's move to Burnley for $26.5 million has been disappointing, with the striker struggling to make an impact due to injuries. Broja's lack of goals and consistent fitness issues have hindered his progress at Burnley. With the club facing a relegation battle, Broja needs to step up and deliver to help his team avoid the drop.
Arnaud Kalimuendo's brief spell at Nottingham Forest ended in disappointment, with the Frenchman failing to make an impact during his time at the club. After a loan move to Eintracht Frankfurt, Kalimuendo has shown promise in the Bundesliga, highlighting his potential. However, his lackluster performances at Forest have been a setback in his career.
Jamie Gittens' move to Chelsea has not lived up to expectations, with the winger struggling to make an impact due to injuries and competition for places. Gittens' limited playing time and lack of goals have raised doubts about his future at the club. With more signings likely, Gittens faces a tough battle to secure a regular spot in the team.
Harvey Elliott's loan move to Aston Villa from Liverpool has not gone as planned, with the midfielder struggling to earn playing time under Unai Emery. Elliott's lack of opportunities at Villa has raised questions about his future at the club. With limited appearances this season, Elliott faces an uncertain future as he looks to make an impact in the Premier League.
In conclusion, the 2025-26 season has seen several high-profile signings fail to meet expectations, with clubs and players alike facing challenges in adapting to new environments. As the season progresses, these players will need to step up and deliver to justify their hefty price tags and secure their futures in the Premier League.