Revisiting the New York Giants' Draft Busts: A Decade of Disappointments
The process of drafting players in the NFL is not an exact science, and sometimes even the most promising picks can turn out to be disappointments for various reasons. Now that the 2026 NFL Draft has concluded, the focus shifts to evaluating past draft picks that didn't quite live up to expectations. Let's take a look back at the New York Giants' draft history over the last decade to identify their five worst picks.
In the 2016 draft, the Giants selected quarterback Davis Webb in the third round, hoping to find a capable backup. However, Webb failed to make an impact and was released after just one season with the team. He later returned to the Giants in 2022 but saw limited playing time during his NFL career.
Moving up in the first round of the 2019 draft, the Giants traded away Day 3 picks to select cornerback Deandre Baker. Despite starting 15 games as a rookie, Baker was released in 2020 following off-field issues. He briefly played for the Chiefs before his NFL career ended prematurely.
Cornerback Aaron Banks showed promise in his rookie season but struggled in the following years, leading to a decline in performance. The Giants opted not to pick up his fifth-year option, and Banks faces a tough battle to secure a spot on the roster in the upcoming season.
Wide receiver Kadarius Toney's tenure with the Giants was marred by injuries and reported lack of effort in preparation and practice. The team traded Toney to the Chiefs in his second season, receiving draft picks in return. Toney's time in New York was short-lived, and he failed to make a significant impact during his stint with the team.
In conclusion, the New York Giants have had their share of draft disappointments over the past decade, with players like Davis Webb, Deandre Baker, Aaron Banks, and Kadarius Toney failing to meet expectations. As the team looks ahead to future drafts, they will aim to make more successful selections to bolster their roster and improve their performance on the field.