Unprecedented Dismissal of U.S. Election Assistance Commission Commissioners Raises Concerns
Votebeat is a non-profit news organization that focuses on reporting voting access and election administration issues in the United States. The organization offers a free weekly newsletter for the latest updates on these topics.
President Donald Trump recently dismissed all three remaining members of the U.S. Election Assistance Commission, effectively eliminating the only federal agency dedicated to election administration. The two Democratic commissioners, Thomas Hicks and Benjamin Hovland, were informed of their termination via email, while the Republican commissioner, Christy McCormick, was allowed to resign. The agency's fourth commissioner, Republican Donald Palmer, had already left earlier in the year.
The firings have left the commission without any commissioners, preventing it from taking official action until new members are appointed. This move comes shortly after the Supreme Court granted the president the authority to remove leaders of independent agencies, weakening the previous legal framework that protected bipartisan federal commissions from direct White House control.
The Election Assistance Commission was established by Congress after the 2000 election to assist states in improving election administration without federalizing elections. Its responsibilities include distributing federal election funds, maintaining the national mail voter registration form, testing and certifying voting systems, and providing guidance to state and local election officials.
The removal of the EAC commissioners raises questions about the future of bipartisan election agencies and whether they fall under the same removal-power rules as other independent agencies. The Help America Vote Act specifies that the president should consider recommendations from Senate and House leaders when nominating new EAC commissioners, but the process of appointing new commissioners requires Senate confirmation.
The immediate impact of the firings is that the EAC is unable to function, which could hinder its ability to address important election-related issues before the 2026 midterms. The agency's oversight of the federal testing and certification program for voting systems is crucial for ensuring that voting equipment meets federal standards.
The EAC has faced challenges in the past due to vacancies and partisan conflicts, which have affected its ability to carry out its duties effectively. The recent removal of all commissioners at once has once again left the agency in a state of paralysis, just as the 2026 election cycle is getting underway.
In conclusion, the abrupt dismissal of the U.S. Election Assistance Commission's commissioners has raised concerns about the future of election administration in the country. The lack of commissioners has left the agency unable to function, potentially impacting its ability to address critical election-related issues. The implications of these firings on the agency's role in overseeing voting systems and election administration remain uncertain.